Accretion and Avulsion in Virginia: Who Owns Land When the Shoreline Moves?

Published by Jim Lang

Published by Jim Lang · Reviewed: ________

Why this matters for Virginia waterfront owners

Tidewater shorelines change every year. Sand moves along Chesapeake Bay beaches, creeks silt in, marsh edges erode, and nor'easters and hurricanes can reshape a point in a single night. Owners also bulkhead, fill, and build out shorelines, and public projects such as beach nourishment and channel dredging can add sand in front of private property.

Each of these changes raises the same practical questions:

Key terms

What Virginia law says

On tidal waters, ownership generally runs to mean low water

Under Va. Code § 28.2-1202(A) the bounds of tracts of land lying on the bays, rivers, creeks, and shores within the jurisdiction of the Commonwealth, and the rights and privileges of their owners, extend to the mean low-water mark but no farther, except where a creek or river is within the limits of a lawful survey (land held under a special grant or compact). Below that line, ungranted beds generally belong to the Commonwealth under Va. Code § 28.2-1200. This is a rule for tidal and navigable waters; it is not a rule for every Virginia shoreline.

Because the boundary on these waters is tied to a water line rather than a fixed point, it generally moves when the water line moves gradually through accretion, erosion or sea level rise.

Other waters and title-specific exceptions

Our 2021 article, Does the Property Line Move When the Shoreline Changes, discusses situations where the property boundary does not move when the shoreline changes. Virginia's tidal waterfront ownership generally extends to mean low water, subject to statutory and title-specific exceptions. On other waters, the property boundary depends on the deed language:

Riparian owners have a right to accretions

The Supreme Court of Virginia has described the "right to accretions or alluvium" as one of the benefits that comes with riparian land. Lynnhaven Dunes Condominium Ass'n v. City of Virginia Beach, 284 Va. 661, 733 S.E.2d 911 (2012). Here, accretion means gradual deposit of land; land lost gradually is erosion.

Gradual change moves the line; avulsion does not

The Supreme Court of Virginia put the rule this way: "Erosive accretions attach to the land on which they fall. Accessions or abstractions, particle on particle, are so necessary and so general that title cannot be made to depend upon them. When this is all, a stream once a line continues to be the line. But where there is avulsion or sudden change from any cause, natural or artificial, by which a stream leaves its old bed and cuts for itself a new channel, the rule is otherwise, for title cannot be made to depend upon the meanderings of vagrant streams." Woody v. Abrams, 160 Va. 683, 169 S.E. 915 (1933). Woody is about a stream leaving its channel; it is not a holding that fill behind a bulkhead freezes the mean-low-water line.

Man-made changes: filling in does not enlarge riparian rights

When an owner changes the shoreline by fill, a bulkhead, or riprap, the owner cannot use that change to enlarge his or her riparian rights at a neighbor's expense. In Carr v. Kidd, 261 Va. 81, 540 S.E.2d 884 (2001), the Court approved apportioning neighbors' riparian rights as if the fill and other perimeter improvements had not been made, reasoning that a riparian owner may not, by lawful development of his land, enlarge his riparian rights or advance the division line with his neighbors.

Sand placed by public projects: three separate points

Public beach nourishment raises three distinct legal points. They should be read separately, and how they apply to any property depends on the facts.

  1. The common-law rule. A riparian owner generally takes title to land added by accretion, and the right to accretions is one of the owner's riparian rights. Where a stream suddenly leaves its old bed and cuts a new channel (an avulsion), the boundary stays in the old channel.
  2. What Lynnhaven Dunes held on its facts. In Lynnhaven Dunes Condominium Ass'n v. City of Virginia Beach, 284 Va. 661, 733 S.E.2d 911 (2012), owners claimed a city beach replenishment project cut off their riparian rights. The Supreme Court of Virginia held that the circuit court erred in treating the loss of riparian rights from the city's project as non-compensable.
  3. What Va. Code § 28.2-1202(C) now says. Subsection C was added in 2014 and is retroactively effective beginning January 1, 2009. It applies only when all of these conditions are met: (a) sand or other material is placed on state-owned beds channelward of the mean low-water mark; (b) as part of a properly permitted beach nourishment, storm protection, or dredging project; (c) undertaken by a public body; and (d) the public has an established right of use and maintenance on the adjacent land above mean low water (whether established before or after the placement). When it applies, the placement is not deemed a severance or taking of, or an impairment of, the adjacent owner's riparian or littoral rights, and the new land is deemed natural accretion for ownership purposes, but subject to the public's same right of use and maintenance that existed on the adjacent land.

Subsection C does not cover every public project. Whether any compensation claim survives for a particular property is fact-specific and depends on whether each statutory condition is met.

How the rules play out: common scenarios

These are simplified illustrations, not predictions about any property.

  1. Sand slowly builds in front of a Bay beach lot over many years. On tidal water, the owner may argue the new beach is accretion that belongs to the lot and that the boundary has moved seaward with mean low water. Evidence matters: old surveys, aerial photographs, and tide data.
  2. A hurricane cuts a new inlet through a neighbor's point. If the storm makes a stream or channel suddenly leave its old bed and cut a new one, that is an avulsion, and the boundary stays in the old channel. Whether a given change was sudden or gradual is a question of fact.
  3. An owner fills behind a new bulkhead. Artificial fill raises separate ownership, permitting, and riparian-apportionment questions. Those issues should not be resolved merely by labeling the change an avulsion. The owner cannot use the fill to enlarge riparian rights or to move the riparian lines with neighbors, which are drawn as if the fill had not been made. That is an apportionment rule; it does not freeze the mean-low-water line.
  4. A lot on a lake, a pond, a man-made canal, or a non-tidal, non-navigable creek. The general mean-low-water rule does not apply. The boundary depends on deed language.

Accretion, avulsion, and riparian rights

Riparian rights, such as access to navigable water and the right to build qualifying piers, depend on touching the water. If the shoreline moves gradually, the riparian area in front of a lot can shift too. That can affect where a pier may go and how the lines between neighbors are drawn. See our guide to riparian rights in Virginia and how riparian lines are drawn.

Practical steps for owners and buyers

FAQs

What is the difference between accretion and avulsion?

Accretion is gradual, imperceptible buildup of land along the water. An avulsion is a sudden change in which a stream leaves its old bed and cuts a new channel, from any cause, natural or artificial, including a human diversion of the water; the line stays in the old channel (Woody v. Abrams). Artificial fill raises separate ownership, permitting, and riparian-apportionment questions, and those issues should not be resolved merely by labeling the change an avulsion. An owner's fill does not move the riparian lines with neighbors, which are drawn as if the fill had not been made.

If sand builds up in front of my Virginia waterfront home, who owns it?

On tidal bays, rivers, creeks, and shores, land added gradually by accretion generally belongs to the adjoining riparian owner, whose line follows mean low water. That rule is subject to statutory and title-specific exceptions. On lakes, ponds, canals, non-tidal waters, and King's grant land, the answer may depend on deed language, bottomland ownership, navigability, and the nature of the change. Special rules apply to sand from qualifying public projects.

What happens to my property line after a hurricane?

A sudden change in which a stream leaves its old bed and cuts a new channel is an avulsion, and the boundary stays in the old channel. Whether a particular change was sudden or gradual is a question of fact.

Do I lose land to erosion?

On tidal waters and many other navigable waters, land lost gradually to erosion generally reduces the property boundary of the upland. The reason for this is that the property boundary follows mean low water as it gradually moves. Rebuilding lost land can require permits.

Does beach nourishment take away my riparian rights?

Not necessarily, and not always. Va. Code § 28.2-1202(C) applies only when a public body places material channelward of mean low water under a properly permitted nourishment, storm-protection, or dredging project, and the other statutory conditions are met. The statute requires an established public right of use and maintenance on the adjacent land above mean low water, whether that right is established before or after placement of the material. When every condition is met, the placement is not deemed a taking, and the new land is treated as natural accretion subject to that same public use. It does not cover every public project, and whether any claim survives depends on the facts.

How do I prove whether a change was gradual or sudden?

Old surveys, aerial imagery, tide records, storm reports, permit files, and testimony from people who know the shoreline can all be relevant. A surveyor and an attorney can help assemble the record.

Talk to Jim Lang

Every waterfront property is different, and the answer often turns on a survey, a deed, or a permit file. Waterfront Law Group helps Virginia buyers, sellers, owners, and agents sort out waterfront questions before they become expensive disputes. Talk to Jim Lang about your property.

This page provides general information about Virginia law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every property is different; consult a licensed Virginia attorney about your situation.

Talk to Jim Lang

Call (757) 919-4419 Contact us